Switch to ADA Accessible Theme
Close Menu
Miami Injury Lawyer
Call for a Free Consultation
En EspañOl
Personal Injury • Wrongful Death • Medical Malpractice
Miami Injury Lawyer > Blog > Personal Injury > Liability for Failing to Provide Adequate Aid

Liability for Failing to Provide Adequate Aid


As a general rule, people and companies have an obligation to act reasonably so as not to cause unnecessary harm to others. This means not creating or allowing dangerous conditions to exist or taking risky actions that put other people in danger. Failure to do so can expose them to liability for a personal injury claim. However, there is no duty to rescue a person experiencing an emergency. So, while morally reprehensible, it not illegal to watch a person in pain over a broken arm and do nothing to help. Further, when aid is offered, the rescuer is usually immune from civil liability unless certain factors are proven. This exemption of responsibility is to encourage bystanders to help those in need, and in fact, the party who caused the negligence in the first place could be liable to the rescuer if he/she is hurt trying to help the original victim. However, once begun, rescuers are not generally allowed to abruptly abandon a person in an emergency, as this is likely to result in further harm. Sometimes, there is a question about whether aid was undertaken, thus imposing a duty to make a good faith to help. A discussion of when a person has a legal duty to act, and when a rescuer may assume legal liability, despite Good Samaritan laws, will follow below.

When a Person Is Required to Help

As noted above, people are generally not required to put their lives in danger to help someone else. Thus, there is no duty to render aid in most situations. Exceptions to this general rule apply if there is a recognized legally-defined relationship between the parties that creates a greater duty to act. A duty to provide assistance tends to arise in three particular situations:

  • the person rendering aid caused the dangerous condition, such as a driver in a car accident or business owner with a customer who slipped on wet floor;
  • a special relationship existed between the rescuer and the person needing help, e., parent/child or teacher/student; or
  • the rescuer started to provide aid, causing other potential rescuers to abandon offering assistance, leaving the victim in potentially greater danger if the active rescuer stops helping.

As mentioned above, the negligent party may also be liable to pay compensation to a rescuer for injuries sustained if the following are established:

  • the person who caused the emergency acted negligently;
  • the negligence put the victim in imminent danger; and
  • the rescuer acted reasonably in trying to render aid under the circumstances.

When a Rescuer Faces Potential Liability

Good Samaritan laws are primarily aimed at encouraging doctors and other medical professionals to help someone in need, as they are best equipped to provide the most beneficial aid. Giving them immunity from liability helps in this regard, but this immunity is also extended to members of the general public who attempt to rescue someone in an emergency. This immunity is not absolute, and for non-healthcare providers and doctors rendering aid outside a medical facility and without necessary equipment, they can be held liable if:

  • the helper failed to exercise due care and caused additional harm; or
  • the person in danger reasonably relied upon the helper’s undertaking and suffered an injury as a result.

In other words, if the rescuer’s efforts exacerbated or created additional injury, instead of relieving the danger, liability for negligence may follow.

Contact a Florida Personal Injury Attorney

One of the benefits of living in a community is being able to count on others when help is needed. However, when negligence or reckless behavior causes injury, these individuals need to be held accountable. The attorneys at the Miami law firm of Pita Weber Del Prado have years of experience handling many types of personal injury claims, and are available to advise you on your legal options. Contact us for a free consultation.



Facebook Twitter LinkedIn

© 2019 - 2023 Pita Weber Del Prado. All rights reserved.
This law firm website and legal marketing are managed by MileMark Media.